Showing posts with label Barnaby Jack. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Barnaby Jack. Show all posts

Anatomía del 'Jackpot' Digital: Cómo Barnaby Jack Hizo Escupir Dinero a un Cajero Automático

La luz parpadeante del monitor era la única compañía mientras los logs del servidor escupían una anomalía. Una que no debería estar ahí. Hoy no vamos a hablar de un script kiddie intentando tumbar un sitio web con un DDoS. Vamos a desgranar un hito que sacudió los cimientos de la seguridad en el sector financiero: la demostración de Barnaby Jack, el hombre que hizo escupir dinero a un cajero automático.

Hace más de una década, en plena conferencia de seguridad, Jack no solo teorizó; demostró. Dos cajeros automáticos independientes se convirtieron en sus marionetas, dispensando billetes bajo su control. Un acto que grabó su nombre en la historia de la ciberseguridad y que hoy recordamos no como un truco, sino como una lección de ingeniería inversa aplicada a la vida real.

¡ADVERTENCIA! Este análisis se realiza con fines estrictamente educativos e informativos. La explotación de vulnerabilidades en sistemas bancarios es ilegal y conlleva serias consecuencias. Nuestro objetivo es entender las tácticas ofensivas para construir defensas más robustas.

El Telón de Fondo: Un Ecosistema Vulnerable

En aquel entonces, la superficie de ataque de los cajeros automáticos (ATM) era un terreno fértil. No se trataba solo de fuerza bruta o de deslizar una tarjeta clonada. Las vulnerabilidades residían en el propio software que gobernaba estas máquinas, a menudo sistemas operativos anticuados y configuraciones de red laxas.

Los cajeros funcionaban, en esencia, como ordenadores expuestos. Ejecutaban software propietario, a veces con interfaces de programación de aplicaciones (APIs) poco seguras o incluso con puertos de depuración accesibles que permitían la inyección de comandos. La dependencia de sistemas heredados y la lenta adopción de parches de seguridad crearon un caldo de cultivo perfecto para investigadores como Jack.

La conferencia Black Hat de 2010 fue el escenario. Barnaby Jack, con la calma de un cirujano digital, presentó su trabajo. No era magia negra; era ingeniería aplicada con una audacia escalofriante.

La Táctica del 'Jackpot': Anatomía de un Ataque

La demostración de Jack se basó en la explotación de una vulnerabilidad específica en los cajeros automáticos. Su método, apodado "jackpotting", consistía en inyectar código malicioso en el sistema operativo del ATM. Una vez dentro, el código tomaba el control de los mecanismos de dispensación de efectivo.

Fase 1: Acceso Inicial

  1. Identificación del modelo de ATM y su sistema operativo subyacente.
  2. Investigación de vulnerabilidades conocidas o la búsqueda de nuevas fallas en el software del ATM o en sus protocolos de comunicación.
  3. Vector de infección: Esto podría ser a través de un puerto USB, una conexión de red comprometida, o incluso mediante una tarjeta maliciosa previamente insertada. La clave era lograr la ejecución de código arbitrario.

Fase 2: Escalada de Privilegios y Control

  1. Una vez que el código malicioso se ejecutaba, necesitaba obtener privilegios suficientes para interactuar con el hardware del cajero.
  2. El código se comunicaba directamente con el módulo de dispensación de efectivo, enviando comandos para que expulsara el dinero sin la validación de una transacción legítima.

Fase 3: Ejecución del 'Jackpot'

  1. Al enviar una secuencia específica de comandos, el ATM era instruido para dispensar todo el dinero que contenía, o una cantidad predeterminada.

Esta demostración no solo fue impactante por su resultado, sino por la simplicidad aparente de la explotación, que enmascaraba un profundo conocimiento técnico.

El Vector de Ataque: Más Allá del Teclado

Es fundamental entender que estos ataques contra ATMs rara vez se inician de forma remota sin una puerta de entrada física o de red. Los vectores comunes incluyen:

  • Acceso Físico: Un atacante con acceso físico a la máquina podría insertar una memoria USB con el malware o explotar puertos de servicio.
  • Compromiso de Red: Si el cajero está conectado a una red interna y esta red ha sido comprometida, el atacante puede moverse lateralmente hasta alcanzar el ATM.
  • Compromiso del Proveedor de Servicios: A veces, los técnicos de mantenimiento o las empresas que actualizan el software de los ATMs pueden ser el punto de entrada si sus sistemas están comprometidos.

La era de los cajeros como sistemas aislados estaba llegando a su fin. La interconexión, si bien conveniente, abría nuevas avenidas para el adversario.

Fortaleciendo el Perímetro: Lecciones para el Blue Team

La demostración de Barnaby Jack fue una llamada de atención para la industria bancaria. Las lecciones aprendidas son atemporales y cruciales para cualquier entorno que maneje información sensible o activos financieros:

  • Actualización de Software y Parcheo: Mantener los sistemas operativos y las aplicaciones de los ATMs actualizados con los últimos parches de seguridad es primordial. Esto incluye eliminar software obsoleto y versiones de sistemas operativos sin soporte.
  • Seguridad de Red y Segmentación: Los ATMs deben estar en segmentos de red aislados, con firewalls estrictos que restrinjan el acceso solo a los servidores de comunicación necesarios. Se debe implementar la inspección profunda de paquetes (DPI) y sistemas de detección/prevención de intrusiones (IDS/IPS).
  • Endurecimiento del Sistema (Hardening): Deshabilitar puertos de servicio no esenciales (como USBs, si no son requeridos), deshabilitar la ejecución de programas no autorizados y configurar políticas de seguridad robustas en el sistema operativo del ATM.
  • Monitoreo de Integridad de Archivos (FIM): Implementar soluciones FIM para detectar cualquier modificación no autorizada en archivos críticos del sistema o ejecutables.
  • Seguridad Física: Aunque el ataque fue lógico, la seguridad física sigue siendo una primera línea de defensa. Controlar el acceso a las máquinas y a los puertos de servicio es vital.
  • Protocolos de Comunicación Seguros: Asegurar que la comunicación entre el ATM y el servidor central se realice mediante protocolos cifrados y autenticados.

La defensa no es un acto único, es un proceso continuo de adaptación y vigilancia.

Arsenal del Operador/Analista

Para aquellos que se dedican a la caza de amenazas (threat hunting) o al análisis de vulnerabilidades, comprender estas tácticas es clave. El arsenal para investigar este tipo de escenarios defensivamente incluye:

  • Herramientas de Análisis de Red: Wireshark, tcpdump para capturar y analizar el tráfico de red.
  • Herramientas de Análisis de Malware: IDA Pro, Ghidra, x64dbg para ingeniería inversa del software del ATM (si se obtienen muestras legítimamente en entornos de laboratorio).
  • Sistemas de Gestión de Logs (SIEM): Splunk, ELK Stack para recolectar y analizar logs de eventos de seguridad de la red bancaria.
  • Soluciones de EDR/XDR: Para monitorear el comportamiento de endpoints, incluyendo ATMs en entornos corporativos.
  • Libros Clave: "The Web Application Hacker's Handbook" (aunque enfocado en web, los principios de análisis de protocolos y inyección son aplicables), "Practical Reverse Engineering".
  • Certificaciones: OSCP (Offensive Security Certified Professional) para entender las metodologías de ataque, y CISSP (Certified Information Systems Security Professional) para la perspectiva de gestión de la seguridad.

Si bien Barnaby Jack demostró un ataque, el objetivo de un analista defensivo es usar este conocimiento para construir muros más altos.

Preguntas Frecuentes

¿Fue legal lo que hizo Barnaby Jack?

La demostración se realizó en una conferencia de seguridad con fines demostrativos y educativos, sin intención de causar daño financiero. Sin embargo, replicar estas acciones en cajeros automáticos reales sin autorización sería ilegal y se consideraría un delito grave.

¿Siguen siendo vulnerables los cajeros automáticos hoy en día?

La industria ha implementado muchas mejoras de seguridad desde la demostración de Jack. Sin embargo, los sistemas heredados, las configuraciones deficientes y las nuevas amenazas emergentes significan que la vulnerabilidad, aunque reducida, puede persistir. La vigilancia y las actualizaciones son continuas.

¿Qué se puede hacer si un cajero automático parece haber sido manipulado?

Si sospechas que un cajero automático ha sido manipulado o si experimentas un problema con una transacción, debes contactar inmediatamente a tu banco y reportar la situación. No intentes interactuar con el cajero más allá del uso normal.

¿Existen herramientas de código abierto para pentesting de ATMs?

Si bien no hay un equivalente directo de código abierto a herramientas comerciales muy específicas para ATMs, las técnicas de pentesting general, el análisis de red y la ingeniería inversa con herramientas como Ghidra o Wireshark son fundamentales. La comunidad de código abierto contribuye significativamente al conocimiento en estas áreas.

El Contrato: El Futuro de la Seguridad Bancaria

La demostración de Barnaby Jack fue un rayo de luz cegador en la oscuridad de las vulnerabilidades bancarias. Nos obligó a mirar de frente la fragilidad de sistemas que, hasta entonces, parecían inexpugnables. El riesgo no reside solo en el código malicioso que se escribe, sino en la complacencia y la falta de adaptación. Los atacantes seguirán buscando la grieta, la puerta trasera, el error de configuración. La pregunta no es si serás atacado, sino cuándo.

Tu contrato con la seguridad es un compromiso diario. La pregunta que debes hacerte es: ¿Has hecho todo lo posible para cerrar esas puertas antes de que llegue la próxima noche de lluvia de datos? ¿Entiendes realmente la superficie de ataque de tus sistemas críticos?

Tu Desafío: Análisis de Escenarios Defensivos

Imagina que trabajas para un banco y se ha detectado un aumento inusual en las transacciones desde ATMs en una sucursal específica. No hay informes directos de mal funcionamiento, solo un patrón de datos anómalo. ¿Cuáles serían tus primeros 5 pasos para investigar defensivamente esta situación, basándote en las lecciones aprendidas del caso Barnaby Jack?

Deja tu análisis y tus pasos de acción en los comentarios.


Este análisis se basa en el trabajo de Barnaby Jack, un pionero en la investigación de seguridad de ATMs. Su legado continúa inspirando la búsqueda de un ciberespacio más seguro.

Fuente Primaria: YouTube - EL HACKER QUE HIZO ESCUPIR DINERO DE UN CAJERO AUTOMATICO

Para más información técnica y análisis de seguridad, visita:

Explora otros dominios del conocimiento:

Adquiere NFTs únicos a precios accesibles: cha0smagick en Mintable

The Art of the ATM Heist: Deconstructing Ploutus and the Jackpotting Phenomenon

The digital realm whispers tales of audacious heists, where millions vanish into the ether, leaving behind only the ghostly imprint of sophisticated software. This isn't just about stolen cash; it's a deep dive into the mechanics of 'jackpotting', the Ploutus malware, and the shadow of the Carbanak hack. This exposé is the first dispatch from a series dissecting how elite operators extract vast fortunes from the banking infrastructure, one vulnerability at a time. Today, we turn our gaze to Barnaby Jack, the pioneer of jackpotting, and the seismic shift he triggered with the first large-scale attack of its kind.

The network is a battlefield, and ATMs are often the weakest link in the financial perimeter. Understanding how these machines are compromised isn't just about satisfying curiosity; it's about arming yourself with the knowledge to defend against such clandestine operations. This isn't a tutorial for the faint of heart, but a dissection of the enemy's playbook. We'll peel back the layers of the Ploutus malware, dissect its propagation methods, and understand the critical vulnerabilities it exploits, transforming passive cash dispensers into conduits for illicit wealth.

Table of Contents

The Genesis of Jackpotting: Barnaby Jack's Legacy

Barnaby Jack was a ghost in the machine, a digital phantom who saw vulnerabilities where others saw sturdy infrastructure. His groundbreaking work, culminating in the demonstration of "jackpotting" at Black Hat USA in 2010, shattered the illusion of ATM security. He proved that ATMs, far from being tamper-proof vaults, were susceptible to software-driven exploitation. By exploiting vulnerabilities in the communication protocols and operating systems of ATMs, Jack demonstrated how an attacker could essentially command the machine to dispense cash, bypassing the need for physical card skimming or coercion.

This wasn't brute force; it was surgical precision. Jack's research highlighted how outdated software, often running on standard operating systems like Windows CE, created a fertile ground for exploitation. The exploit, essentially a piece of malicious code, was loaded onto the ATM, typically via physical access or a compromised connection. Once executed, it would instruct the cash dispensing mechanism to eject money, often in predetermined patterns, making it appear as if the machine was malfunctioning rather than being actively defrauded.

"The ATM is just a PC with a specialized peripheral. If you can hack the PC, you can hack the peripheral." - A common saying in the underground security circles.

Understanding Ploutus: The Malware at the Core

Ploutus, a name that echoes in the dark corners of the cybercrime underworld, represents the evolution of jackpotting malware. This sophisticated piece of software is designed to directly interact with the ATM's internal systems, primarily the Executive Business Processes (XFS) service layer, which manages hardware peripherals like cash dispensers, card readers, and PIN pads. Ploutus doesn't rely on traditional methods of stealing card data; instead, it takes direct control.

The typical attack chain involves an attacker gaining initial access to the ATM's network. This is often achieved through physical means, such as connecting a laptop to an accessible port, or through sophisticated network intrusion techniques that target the financial institution's internal systems. Once inside, the Ploutus malware is deployed. It communicates with the ATM's CPU, sending specific commands that trigger the cash dispenser to eject bills. The malware often presents a fake interface on the ATM screen, guiding the attacker through the process and allowing them to select the denomination and quantity of cash to dispense.

Different variants of Ploutus have emerged over time, each refining the attack methodology. Some versions are designed to be loaded via USB drives, while others leverage network propagation. A key feature of Ploutus is its ability to avoid detection by standard antivirus software by employing sophisticated evasion techniques. Its primary goal is to enable 'dispense' commands, effectively turning the ATM into a money printing machine for the criminal.

The Genesis of Jackpotting: Barnaby Jack's Legacy

Barnaby Jack was a spectral figure in the cybersecurity landscape, a researcher who unveiled the hidden fragility of modern ATMs. His seminal work, unveiled at Black Hat USA in 2010, initiated the era of 'jackpotting'. Jack meticulously demonstrated how ATMs, often running on legacy operating systems like Windows CE, possessed critical vulnerabilities. He showed that by introducing custom malware, an attacker could bypass traditional security measures and command the machine to dispense cash directly, rendering card data theft obsolete for this specific attack vector.

This was not about brute force; it was about exploiting the underlying architecture. Jack's exploit essentially acted as a digital key, unlocking the cash dispenser. Once executed on the ATM, the malware would issue a specific command sequence, compelling the machine to eject currency. This technique allowed criminals to bypass the need for compromised cards or user credentials, focusing solely on orchestrating the machine's mechanical functions.

"An ATM is just a PC with a specialized peripheral. If you can hack the PC, you can hack the peripheral." - A common adage in the underground technical community.

Understanding Ploutus: The Malware at the Core

The Ploutus malware family represents a significant advancement in ATM jackpotting. This malicious software is engineered to directly interface with the ATM's hardware management systems, often targeting the Extended Functionality for Financial Services (XFS) interface. Unlike traditional ATM fraud which focuses on stealing card information, Ploutus bypasses these steps entirely, aiming for direct cash dispensing. The attack typically begins with an intruder gaining network access to the ATM, either through physical connection or sophisticated network infiltration targeting the financial institution.

Once deployed, Ploutus sends commands to the ATM's central processing unit, initiating the cash dispensing mechanism. Variants of Ploutus have emerged over time, with different propagation methods, from USB drives to network exploits. Sophisticated evasion techniques are often employed to remain undetected by standard security software. The core function of Ploutus is to enable unauthorized cash disbursements, transforming vulnerable ATMs into direct revenue streams for cybercriminals.

Evolution of the Attack Vector: From Physical Access to Remote Exploitation

The early days of jackpotting, pioneered by Barnaby Jack, often required a degree of physical proximity. An attacker might need to connect a laptop directly to an internal port on the ATM, or perhaps exploit a vulnerability in the maintenance interface. However, as security measures evolved, so did the sophistication of the attackers. The focus shifted towards remote exploitation, allowing criminals to initiate these attacks from anywhere in the world.

This transition involved exploiting vulnerabilities within the broader banking network. Attackers would target the central servers that manage and communicate with ATM fleets. By compromising these central systems, they could push malicious code, like Ploutus variants, to multiple ATMs simultaneously, vastly increasing the scale and impact of their operations. This shift from localized physical access to widespread network compromise marked a critical escalation in the threat landscape. It underscored the interconnectedness of financial systems and how a single breach at the network core could compromise countless endpoints.

The Carbanak Connection: A Wider Threat

The Carbanak gang, a notorious cybercriminal syndicate, brought the concept of ATM jackpotting into the realm of highly organized, state-sponsored or state-tolerated cybercrime. While not solely focused on ATMs, Carbanak (and its successor, Cobalt Strike) utilized tools and techniques that encompassed jackpotting operations, often alongside other forms of financial fraud and corporate espionage. Their attacks were characterized by their stealth, sophistication, and immense financial gains.

The Carbanak operation demonstrated that jackpotting wasn't just the domain of independent hackers but could be a component of larger, more complex cyber-espionage and financial theft campaigns. They leveraged a blend of custom malware, legitimate remote administration tools, and social engineering to infiltrate banking networks and execute their schemes. The scale of their operations, often involving millions of dollars stolen from various financial institutions globally, highlighted the systemic risks posed by such advanced persistent threats (APTs).

Defense Strategies for Financial Institutions

Protecting against jackpotting and sophisticated ATM malware requires a multi-layered defense strategy. Financial institutions must move beyond perimeter security and implement robust internal controls and continuous monitoring. Key strategies include:

  • Endpoint Security Hardening: Regularly updating ATM software to patch known vulnerabilities, disabling unnecessary ports and services, and implementing strong access controls for maintenance. This includes ensuring that only authorized personnel with secure credentials can physically access ATM hardware or management interfaces.
  • Network Segmentation: Isolating ATM networks from the broader corporate network. This prevents a breach in one area from easily propagating to the ATMs. Strict firewall rules and intrusion detection/prevention systems (IDPS) are crucial here.
  • Malware Detection and Analysis: Employing advanced security solutions capable of detecting zero-day threats and sophisticated malware like Ploutus. This includes behavioral analysis and anomaly detection tools that can identify unusual activity on ATMs, such as unexpected cash dispensing commands.
  • Physical Security: While the threat is digital, physical access remains a common entry point. Secure physical access to ATMs and their maintenance panels is paramount.
  • Incident Response Preparedness: Having a well-defined and regularly tested incident response plan specifically for ATM compromises. This ensures a swift and effective reaction when an attack is detected, minimizing financial and reputational damage.
  • Regular Audits and Penetration Testing: Proactively identifying weaknesses through rigorous internal and external security assessments. This includes simulated jackpotting attacks to test the effectiveness of existing defenses.

The battle against ATM malware is ongoing. It requires constant vigilance, adaptation, and investment in cutting-edge security technologies. Ignoring these threats opens the door to massive financial losses and reputational damage.

Verdict of the Engineer: Is ATM Security a Myth?

Let's be clear: ATM security is a continuous, uphill battle, not a solved problem. While manufacturers and financial institutions invest heavily in defenses, the fundamental architecture of many ATMs, often relying on older operating systems and communication protocols, presents inherent weaknesses. The success of attacks like Ploutus and the broader implications of the Carbanak operation suggest that a complete elimination of risk is currently unattainable. ATMs, much like any complex connected device not designed with modern security principles from the ground up, remain attractive targets. The ongoing arms race between attackers developing new malware variants and defenders patching vulnerabilities means that vigilance is the only true security. While not entirely a myth, robust ATM security requires constant adaptation and a proactive, offensive mindset to stay ahead of evolving threats.

Arsenal of the Operator/Analyst

  • For Malware Analysis:
    • Sandboxing Solutions: Cuckoo Sandbox, Any.Run, Hybrid Analysis for dynamic analysis.
    • Reverse Engineering Tools: IDA Pro, Ghidra, x64dbg for static and dynamic code analysis.
    • Network Analysis: Wireshark, tcpdump for capturing and analyzing network traffic.
    • Memory Forensics: Volatility Framework for extracting information from RAM dumps.
  • For Penetration Testing & Network Reconnaissance:
    • Metasploit Framework: For developing and executing exploit code.
    • Nmap: Essential for network discovery and port scanning.
    • Burp Suite (Pro): While primarily for web applications, its proxy capabilities can be invaluable for intercepting and analyzing traffic to/from network devices.
  • Essential Reading:
    • "The Web Application Hacker's Handbook: Finding and Exploiting Chemical Vulnerabilities"
    • "Practical Malware Analysis: The Hands-On Guide to Dissecting Malicious Software"
    • Research papers and advisories from security conferences like Black Hat and DEF CON.
  • Certifications to Aim For:
    • Certified Ethical Hacker (CEH)
    • Offensive Security Certified Professional (OSCP)
    • Certified Information Systems Security Professional (CISSP) - for a broader security perspective.

Practical Workshop: Analyzing Malware Behavior

Understanding how malware like Ploutus operates requires stepping into the analyst's shoes. While directly analyzing live ATM malware is restricted and dangerous, we can simulate the process using publicly available samples or by observing the behavior of similar banking trojans in a controlled environment. The goal is to understand the exploit chain and the malware's persistence mechanisms.

  1. Environment Setup: Prepare a dedicated, isolated virtual machine (VM) for malware analysis. Ensure it has no network connection to your host or other production systems. Install necessary analysis tools like Wireshark, Process Monitor (Procmon), and a disassembler/debugger (Ghidra or IDA Free).
  2. Malware Acquisition (Ethical): Obtain a sample of banking malware (from reputable research sites or sandboxes) or a benign tool exhibiting similar behaviors. Never acquire malware from untrusted sources.
  3. Initial Observation: Run the malware within the isolated VM. Use Process Monitor to log all file system, registry, and process activity. Observe what files are created, modified, or deleted, and what registry keys are accessed or created.
  4. Network Traffic Analysis: Use Wireshark to capture network traffic originating from the VM. Look for connections to suspicious IP addresses or domains, unusual protocols, or data exfiltration patterns. Mimic how Ploutus would attempt to communicate with a command-and-control server.
  5. Code Dissection (Static Analysis): Load the malware executable into Ghidra or IDA Free. Analyze the code structure, identify key functions, strings, and API calls. Look for logic related to hardware interaction, network communication, or process injection – core components of jackpotting malware.
  6. Dynamic Analysis: Use a debugger (like x64dbg or the debugger integrated into your VM tools) to step through the malware's execution. Examine memory contents, register values, and understand how the malware manipulates system processes. This helps reveal runtime behaviors and obfuscation techniques.
  7. Reporting: Document all findings meticulously. This includes the malware's initial entry vector (if simulated), persistence mechanisms, network activities, and core functionalities. This detailed report is what a threat intelligence analyst would produce.

This hands-on approach, even with simulated elements, provides a critical understanding of how attackers operate and what indicators of compromise (IoCs) to look for.

FAQ: ATM Heists and Cybersecurity

Q1: Is jackpotting still a common method for ATM theft?
A1: While perhaps less prevalent than card skimming due to increased security, jackpotting remains a significant threat, especially with advanced malware like Ploutus. Attackers continuously adapt their methods.

Q2: Can a regular person get infected by ATM malware?
A2: It's highly unlikely that a regular user interacting with an ATM would get infected. Malware like Ploutus targets the ATM's internal operating system, not the user's device or card data directly in most cases.

Q3: What's the difference between jackpotting and skimming?
A3: Skimming involves stealing card data (magnetic stripe information and PINs) to create counterfeit cards. Jackpotting directly commands the ATM to dispense cash without needing a valid card transaction.

Q4: How much money can be stolen in a jackpotting attack?
A4: Significant amounts, potentially tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars per compromised ATM, depending on its cash capacity and the attacker's control over the dispensing mechanism.

Q5: Are ATMs running modern operating systems more secure?
A5: Generally, yes. ATMs using up-to-date, secure operating systems with robust security configurations are much harder to compromise than those still running legacy systems like Windows XP or older. However, the complexity of integration and network security remains critical.

The Contract: Secure Your Digital Assets

The digital streets are fraught with peril. The story of Ploutus and ATM jackpotting is a stark reminder that even seemingly robust systems can harbor critical vulnerabilities. Understanding these threats is the first step towards mitigation. For financial institutions, this means investing heavily in up-to-date security protocols, continuous monitoring, and rapid incident response. For individual users, it means being aware of phishing attempts and protecting your credentials. The code is the language of the attacker, and understanding it is how we build stronger defenses.

Now, ponder this:

Given the evolution from physical access to network-level exploits for jackpotting, what specific network traffic anomalies would you, as a security analyst, prioritize monitoring within a financial institution's ATM network to detect a Ploutus-like attack in its early stages? Detail at least three distinct traffic patterns or indicators.