Showing posts with label disaster recovery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label disaster recovery. Show all posts

Disaster Recovery Simulation: Unveiling the True Cyber Threat Landscape

The digital realm is a battlefield where shadows move and threats evolve daily. In this ceaseless war, preparedness isn't a luxury; it's the grim calculus of survival. When focusing on the most probable and impactful threats, disaster preparedness shifts from a theoretical exercise to a stark reality check. Christopher Tarantino, CEO of Epicenter Innovation, recently conducted a disaster recovery exercise with a university's leadership team. The outcome? A chilling epiphany regarding the profound cyber and financial repercussions of a potential digital catastrophe. This isn't about hypothetical scenarios; it's about forcing leadership to confront the ghosts in their machine.

This post is an analysis of that revelation, dissecting the anatomy of such an exercise and outlining the defensive strategies necessary to fortify against the inevitable. We'll move beyond the comforting hum of servers to examine the raw, unvarnished truth of cyber vulnerability.

Table of Contents

The Leadership Dichotomy: Prioritizing the Probable

Leadership often operates under a veil of perceived control, focusing on the threats that manifest with the loudest alarms. However, the most insidious threats are often the quietest, the ones that exploit subtle misconfigurations or human error. Tarantino highlights the critical importance of pre- and post-disaster education, not just for IT staff, but for the entire executive strata. When a disaster strikes, it’s not just about restoring systems; it’s about understanding the business continuity and the cascading financial fallout. The exercise forces a shift from reactive measures to a predictive, proactive stance, identifying the most likely attack vectors before they become actual exploits.

"The goal isn't to predict the future, but to build resilience so that the future, whatever it may hold, unfolds optimally." - Unknown

Anatomy of a Disaster Recovery Exercise

A well-structured disaster recovery (DR) exercise is more than a drill; it's a simulated battlefield designed to expose weaknesses under pressure. It typically involves:

  1. Scenario Definition: Identifying plausible threat scenarios (e.g., ransomware attack, data breach, system failure).
  2. Objective Setting: Defining clear goals for the exercise (e.g., response time, communication protocols, data restoration capabilities).
  3. Team Mobilization: Assembling key personnel from IT, leadership, legal, and communications departments.
  4. Simulation Execution: Walking through the defined scenario, replicating the actions and decision-making processes that would occur during a real incident.
  5. After-Action Review (AAR): A critical debriefing session to identify successes, shortfalls, and lessons learned. This is where the "eye-opening" happens, confronting the gap between planned response and actual capability.

The effectiveness of the exercise hinges on its realism and the willingness of participants to engage truthfully, even when the findings are uncomfortable.

The University Scenario: A Wake-Up Call

Tarantino’s engagement with a university leadership team presented a poignant case study. The exercise wasn't merely a technical walkthrough; it was a carefully crafted narrative designed to elicit genuine reactions from those at the helm. By simulating a significant cyber event – perhaps a sophisticated ransomware attack locking down critical academic and administrative systems – the leadership team was forced to confront the immediate operational paralysis. Imagine student records inaccessible, research data compromised, and essential services grinding to a halt. This wasn't a distant possibility; it was a simulated present, demanding immediate, high-stakes decisions.

Quantifying the Cyber and Financial Impact

This is where the true "eye-opening" occurs. Beyond the technical disruption, the exercise forces a tangible assessment of the financial damage. Consider the direct costs:

  • Ransom payments (if applicable): A potentially astronomical sum demanded by threat actors.
  • System restoration and data recovery: Significant investment in skilled personnel and specialized tools.
  • Legal and regulatory fines: Especially pertinent with student data and research IP involved, leading to potential GDPR, HIPAA, or FERPA violations.
  • Reputational damage: The erosion of trust among students, faculty, donors, and the wider academic community can have long-term financial implications.
  • Business interruption costs: Lost revenue from halted operations, research delays, and student recruitment impacts.

By quantifying these elements during the simulation, the leadership team moved from abstract cybersecurity concerns to concrete financial risks, making the need for robust defenses undeniable.

Hardening the Perimeter: Proactive Defense

The insights gained from a DR exercise are valueless if not translated into action. Proactive defense is the counter-offensive to simulated chaos. This involves:

  • Robust Incident Response Plan: A living document, regularly tested and updated, outlining clear roles, responsibilities, and communication channels.
  • Data Backup and Recovery Strategy: Implementing a comprehensive strategy with offsite and immutable backups, regularly verified for integrity.
  • Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR): Deploying advanced solutions to detect and neutralize threats at the endpoint level.
  • Network Segmentation: Isolating critical systems to prevent lateral movement of attackers.
  • Security Awareness Training: Empowering all personnel, especially leadership, with the knowledge to identify and report suspicious activities, bridging the human element.
  • Threat Hunting: Proactively searching for undetected threats within the network, assuming a breach has already occurred.

Your network is only as strong as its weakest link. Continuous assessment and fortification are paramount.

Arsenal of the Operator/Analyst

To effectively conduct and respond to cyber threats, a seasoned operator or analyst relies on a specialized toolkit and continuous learning:

  • Essential Software:
    • SIEM Platforms (e.g., Splunk, ELK Stack): For centralized log management and threat detection.
    • EDR Solutions (e.g., CrowdStrike, SentinelOne): For advanced endpoint threat hunting and response.
    • Network Traffic Analysis Tools (e.g., Zeek, Wireshark): For deep packet inspection and anomaly detection.
    • Threat Intelligence Platforms: To stay abreast of the latest adversary tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs).
  • Key Certifications: Pursuing advanced certifications like OSCP (Offensive Security Certified Professional) for offensive insights, or CISSP (Certified Information Systems Security Professional) for comprehensive security management principles. These are not just badges; they represent a tested level of expertise that informs defensive strategy.
  • Critical Literature:
    • "The Web Application Hacker's Handbook" - A foundational text for understanding web vulnerabilities.
    • "Network Security Assessment" by Chris McNab - For deep dives into network defense.
    • "Applied Network Security Monitoring" by Chris Sanders and Jason Smith - For practical threat hunting techniques.

Investing in these resources is investing in the ability to anticipate and neutralize threats before they escalate.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the primary goal of a disaster recovery exercise?

The primary goal is to test and validate an organization's disaster recovery plan, identify gaps in preparedness, train personnel, and improve response capabilities under simulated crisis conditions.

How often should disaster recovery exercises be conducted?

Regularity is key. For critical systems, exercises should ideally be conducted at least annually, with more frequent, smaller-scale drills for specific components or scenarios.

Who should participate in a disaster recovery exercise?

Key stakeholders should participate, including IT/security teams, executive leadership, legal counsel, communications, and representatives from critical business units.

What is the difference between a disaster recovery exercise and a business continuity exercise?

A DR exercise focuses on restoring IT systems and data after a disruption. A business continuity exercise focuses on maintaining essential business functions during and after a disaster, which may involve IT but also PEOPLE, PROCESSES, and FACILITIES.

The Contract: Securing the Digital Fortress

The university leadership, confronted with the stark reality of a simulated cyber catastrophe, now faces a critical decision: to continue operating in a state of high-risk vulnerability or to invest strategically in their digital defenses. The contract is simple: understand the threat, quantify the impact, and implement robust, tested countermeasures. This isn't a one-time fix; it's a perpetual commitment to vigilance. Your challenge: Analyze your organization's most critical digital assets. Identify the top three cyber threats that could cripple them. Then, formulate a concise, actionable mitigation strategy (max 100 words) for each threat. Post your strategy in the comments below. Let’s see who’s truly fortifying their digital fortress.

Start learning cybersecurity for free: https://ift.tt/iycvFPW

View Cyber Work Podcast transcripts and additional episodes: https://ift.tt/HInCFst

For more hacking info and free hacking tutorials visit: https://ift.tt/kmuJcRj

at No comments:
Labels: , , , , , , ,

Cloudflare's Recurring Outages: A Deep Dive into Resilience and Mitigation

The digital ether crackled with frustration. Another day, another cascading failure at the hands of a seemingly indispensable service. Cloudflare, the omnipresent guardian of the web's performance and security, blinked out for much of the world, leaving a trail of inaccessible websites and irate users in its wake. This wasn't a novel script; it feels like a recurring nightmare in the theatre of modern infrastructure. While this particular incident might not have reached the catastrophic scale of prior meltdowns, its duration – a full hour of digital darkness for many – is a stark reminder of our fragile interconnectedness. Today, we dissect this event not as a mere news flash, but as a case study in the critical importance of infrastructure resilience, the anatomy of such failures, and the defensive strategies every organization must employ.

Table of Contents

Understanding the Incident: The Anatomy of a Cloudflare Outage

The recent Cloudflare outage, while perhaps less dramatic than its predecessors, underscores a persistent vulnerability in relying on single points of failure for critical internet services. When Cloudflare falters, it’s not just one website that goes dark; it’s potentially millions. This incident serves as a potent reminder that even sophisticated Content Delivery Networks (CDNs) and security providers are not immune to complex internal issues or external pressures that can cascade into widespread service disruption. The immediate aftermath is characterized by a surge of support tickets, frantic social media activity, and a palpable sense of unease among businesses that depend on continuous online presence. For defenders, this is not just an inconvenience; it's a live demonstration of distributed system fragility and a siren call to reassess our own contingency plans.

Impact Analysis: Who Was Hit?

The impact of a Cloudflare outage is broad and indiscriminate. Websites serving a global audience, from e-commerce giants and financial institutions to small blogs and informational sites, all face the same digital void. The immediate consequence is a loss of accessibility, translating directly into:
  • Lost Revenue: For e-commerce and service-based businesses, downtime equals direct financial loss. Transactions fail, customers are turned away, and potential sales vanish into the ether.
  • Brand Damage: A website that is consistently or even intermittently unavailable erodes user trust and damages brand reputation. It signals unreliability and a lack of professional commitment.
  • Operational Paralysis: Many organizations rely on Cloudflare not just for content delivery but also for security features like DDoS mitigation, WAF, and API shielding. An outage can cripple their security posture and operational continuity.
  • Degraded User Experience: For end-users, encountering a non-responsive website creates frustration and encourages them to seek alternatives, often permanently.
The "not quite as bad as the one last year or the year before" sentiment, while perhaps true in scale, misses the core point: *any* hour of significant global outage is unacceptable for services that form the backbone of the internet.

Root Cause and Technical Breakdown (Based on Cloudflare's Post-Mortem)

Cloudflare's own post-mortem (accessible via the provided blog link) typically delves into the technical specifics. Without relitigating their exact explanation, these outages often stem from:
  • Configuration Changes Gone Wrong: A faulty update pushed to their global network can have immediate and widespread repercussions. This is a common culprit in complex distributed systems where a single error can propagate rapidly.
  • Software Bugs: Less frequently, a latent bug in their core software can be triggered under specific conditions, leading to system instability.
  • Hardware Failures: While Cloudflare's infrastructure is highly redundant, a cascading failure involving multiple hardware components in critical data centers could theoretically lead to an outage.
  • External Attacks (Less Likely for Core Infrastructure Failure): While Cloudflare excels at mitigating external attacks against its clients, internal failures of this magnitude are typically attributed to self-inflicted issues rather than external exploitation of Cloudflare's core infrastructure itself.
The key lesson here is that even the architects of internet resilience can stumble. Their process for rolling out changes, rigorously testing them, and having robust rollback mechanisms is under constant scrutiny.

Defensive Strategies for Your Infrastructure

This incident isn't just about Cloudflare; it's a wake-up call for every IT professional and business owner. Relying solely on any single third-party service, no matter how reputable, is a gamble. Here are actionable defensive strategies:
  1. Multi-CDN Strategy: While complex and costly, a multi-CDN approach ensures that if one provider fails, traffic can be rerouted to another. This isn't just about performance; it's about survival.
  2. Robust Caching and Offline Capabilities: For certain types of content and applications, implementing advanced caching strategies and designing for graceful degradation or even offline functionality can mitigate the impact of external service disruptions.
  3. Independent Infrastructure for Critical Services: Identify your absolute mission-critical services. For these, consider dedicated, self-hosted, or geographically distributed infrastructure that is not dependent on a single external CDN.
  4. Real-time Monitoring and Alerting: Implement comprehensive monitoring that checks not only the availability of your application but also the health of your CDN. Set up alerts for deviations from normal behavior.
  5. Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery (BCDR) Plans: Regularly review and test your BCDR plans. Ensure they include scenarios for third-party provider outages. What is your communication plan? Who makes the call to switch providers or activate failover systems?
  6. Vendor Risk Management: Understand the SLAs of your providers. What are their guarantees? What are their stated recovery times? Critically, what is their track record?
 

The Engineer's Verdict: Resilience Over Convenience

Cloudflare offers immense convenience, performance gains, and security benefits. It's the default choice for many because it simplifies complex tasks. However, this outage, like its predecessors, highlights that convenience can breed complacency. True resilience in the digital age often demands a more distributed, multi-layered approach, even if it means increased complexity and cost. The question isn't *if* a provider will fail, but *when*, and how prepared you will be. Blind faith in a single vendor is a vulnerability waiting to be exploited by the unpredictable nature of complex systems.

Operator's Arsenal: Tools and Knowledge

To navigate the landscape of internet fragility and build robust defenses, an operator needs more than just tactical tools; they need a mindset.
  • Monitoring & Alerting: Prometheus and Grafana for deep system insight, and UptimeRobot or Pingdom for external checks.
  • Multi-CDN Management: Solutions like Akamai, Fastly, or even strategic use of cloud provider CDNs (e.g., AWS CloudFront, Azure CDN) in parallel.
  • DNS Failover: Services that offer advanced DNS management with rapid failover capabilities based on health checks.
  • Caching Layers: Advanced reverse proxies like Nginx, or distributed caching systems like Redis or Memcached.
  • Threat Intelligence Platforms: For understanding potential external pressures on infrastructure providers.
  • Cloudflare Documentation & Blog: Essential reading to understand their architecture and failure points.
  • Books: "Designing Data-Intensive Applications" by Martin Kleppmann (for understanding distributed systems), "The Web Application Hacker's Handbook" (for understanding how applications interact with infrastructure).
  • Certifications: While not directly for outages, certifications like AWS Certified Solutions Architect or vendor-neutral ones like CCNA/CCNP build foundational knowledge critical for network resilience.

FAQ: Cloudflare's Outages

Why do Cloudflare outages happen?

Cloudflare outages are typically caused by complex internal issues, often related to configuration changes affecting their global network, software bugs, or occasionally, unexpected hardware behavior under load. They are rarely due to direct external attacks on Cloudflare's core infrastructure itself.

How can my website survive a Cloudflare outage?

Implement strategies like multi-CDN, robust caching, designing for graceful degradation, and having a well-tested disaster recovery plan. Reducing reliance on a single point of failure is key.

What should I do during a Cloudflare outage?

First, verify the outage through reliable sources like Cloudflare's status page. Then, assess the impact on your own services. If you have failover mechanisms, consider activating them. Communicate with your users if your services are affected.

Is Cloudflare still safe to use?

Cloudflare remains a highly valuable service for performance and security. However, like any critical infrastructure provider, it's essential to understand its limitations and build redundancy into your own architecture rather than relying on it as your sole point of operation.

The Contract: Fortifying Your Digital Perimeter

The digital world is a constantly shifting battlefield. Today's outage is a stark reminder that the infrastructure we depend on is not infallible. Your contract with the internet is not merely about using a service; it's about understanding its inherent risks and proactively building defenses. The convenience of a single, powerful provider is a siren song. True security and reliability lie in distributed architectures, rigorous testing, and a constant state of preparedness. Your challenge: Audit your current third-party dependencies. Identify the single points of failure in your digital supply chain. Map out a plan, however incremental, to introduce redundancy and resilience. Don't wait for the next outage to become your own crisis. The network is a jungle; prepare for its wild swings.
at No comments:
Labels: , , , , , , , ,

The Unbreakable Chain: Mastering Data Backup Against Ransomware Threats

The digital realm is a battlefield. Every byte is a potential casualty, and ransomware is the ghost in the machine, holding your critical data hostage. In this war, your most potent weapon isn't a firewall or an IDS; it's your backup strategy. Not just any backup, but a robust, tested, and impenetrable chain of recovery. Today, we dissect what it truly means to have data resilience in the face of an existential cyber threat.

For decades, the trenches of data backup and recovery have been commanded by figures like Curtis Preston, affectionately known as "Mr. Backup." With a history stretching back to 1993, Preston is more than an enthusiast; he's a veteran. Author of four books, host of the "Restore it all" podcast, founder of backupcentral.com, and a leading voice for Druva, his insights are forged in the crucible of countless data crises.

This isn't just about restoring files after a coffee spill. We're talking about the grim reality of ransomware, where your data is encrypted, your operations halted, and your reputation on the line. The conversation around disaster recovery (DR) and ransomware defense demands that the data recovery expert and the information security chief become unlikely allies, sharing intel and strategies. Because in the chaos of a breach, synergy is survival.

Preston also challenges long-held beliefs, even questioning the gospel of tape backup systems. Are we clinging to outdated dogma? Let's find out.

Table of Contents

The Genesis: Three Decades in the Trenches

Preston's journey began in 1993, a time when data was measured in megabytes and recovery was often a hands-on, physical process. Over thirty years, the landscape has transformed dramatically. From the advent of networked storage to cloud-native solutions, the evolution is staggering. Yet, the fundamental principle remains: without a reliable copy, your data is ephemeral.

"The fundamental principle of data backup hasn't changed, only the tools and the threats have become exponentially more sophisticated."

Data Duplication and Recovery Speed in Disasters

When disaster strikes, especially a ransomware attack, the speed of recovery can be the difference between a minor setback and a catastrophic business failure. The concept of data duplication during a disaster is critical. It's not just about having multiple copies, but about having them accessible and in a state that allows for rapid restoration. This involves understanding RPO (Recovery Point Objective) and RTO (Recovery Time Objective) not as abstract metrics, but as vital components of operational survival. Ransomware aims to obliterate your ability to meet these objectives.

The Unsung Benefit of Physical Backups

In an era dominated by cloud and virtualized environments, the humble physical backup often gets overlooked. However, for certain scenarios, particularly in the face of sophisticated threats like ransomware, physical backups can offer a critical air gap. An immutable, offline copy cannot be compromised by a network-based attack. This isolation provides a final bastion, a safety net that purely online solutions might not guarantee. The strategy here isn't necessarily to abandon digital, but to intelligently integrate physical resilience.

Common Mistakes in Long-Term Backup Strategies

Achieving long-term backup success requires more than just scheduling jobs. Many organizations stumble by overlooking key aspects:

  • Infrequent Testing: Backups are only as good as their last successful restore test. Neglecting this is akin to buying a fire extinguisher and never checking if it works.
  • Lack of Immutability: In the age of ransomware, backups must be immutable – unchangeable. If an attacker can encrypt your backups, your entire strategy collapses.
  • Inadequate Retention Policies: Striking the right balance between storage costs and necessary retention periods is crucial. Too short, and you lose historical data; too long, and costs escalate unnecessarily.
  • Ignoring the 3-2-1 Rule (and its modern variants): While the classic 3-2-1 rule (3 copies, 2 media types, 1 offsite) is a strong foundation, modern threats demand considering air-gapped and immutable copies as well.

Mistakes in these areas can render your "backup" effectively useless when you need it most.

Navigating the Labyrinth of Recovery Issues

The journey from a successful backup to a fully restored system is fraught with potential pitfalls. Issues can arise from corrupted backup files, incompatible restoration media, or a lack of understanding of the complex interdependencies within the IT environment. Often, the data recovery team and the information security team operate in silos, leading to miscommunication and delays during a critical incident. This friction slows down the recovery process, giving attackers more time to solidify their foothold or exfiltrate more data.

Defining the Borders of Disaster Recovery

While disaster recovery plans are essential, it's crucial to understand their limitations. A DR plan is designed to bring systems back online after a disruptive event. However, it doesn't inherently prevent the event itself. In the context of ransomware, a DR plan might allow you to restore systems, but it doesn't guarantee that the malware, or the vulnerabilities it exploited, have been eradicated. Post-recovery analysis and thorough threat hunting are vital to ensure the threat is neutralized before full operations resume.

Encryption: A Double-Edged Sword

Encryption plays a dual role in data protection. On one hand, encrypting your backups adds a layer of security, protecting sensitive data even if the backup media falls into the wrong hands. It can also be a key component in ransomware defense, making backups harder for attackers to decrypt and misuse. However, managing encryption keys is paramount. Lost keys mean lost data, and poorly implemented encryption can itself become a vulnerability. Furthermore, attacking unencrypted data is often a primary objective for ransomware actors.

Careers in Backup and Recovery

The field of backup and recovery, often seen as a niche area, is a critical component of the cybersecurity ecosystem. Roles range from backup administrators and engineers to disaster recovery specialists and data protection evangelists. The increasing complexity of data and the persistent threat of ransomware mean that skilled professionals in this domain are in high demand. Understanding the intricacies of data protection is a valuable asset for any IT or cybersecurity career path.

For those looking to enter this field:

  • Learn the Fundamentals: Understand storage technologies, networking, operating systems, and virtualization.
  • Master Backup Software: Get hands-on experience with enterprise-grade backup solutions.
  • Study DR Principles: Familiarize yourself with RPO, RTO, and business continuity planning.
  • Cloud Expertise: Knowledge of cloud backup and recovery services is increasingly vital.
  • Security Mindset: Understand how backups fit into the broader cybersecurity strategy.

The demand for these skills is only set to grow.

The Next Five to Ten Years in Data Protection

The future of data protection will likely be shaped by several key trends:

  • AI-Driven Protection: Artificial intelligence will play a larger role in anomaly detection within backups and in predicting potential threats.
  • Immutable Cloud Backups: Cloud providers will continue to enhance immutable storage options, making them more accessible and robust.
  • Zero Trust Architectures: Backup systems will increasingly operate under zero-trust principles, requiring strict authentication and authorization for every access.
  • SaaS Data Protection: As more businesses rely on SaaS applications, dedicated SaaS data protection solutions will become indispensable.
  • Enhanced Ransomware Resilience: Solutions will focus not just on recovery, but on active defense and rapid containment during an attack.

The evolution is constant, requiring continuous learning and adaptation.

Veredicto del Ingeniero: ¿Vale la pena adoptar una estrategia de backup robusta?

Absolutely. This isn't a choice; it's a prerequisite for survival in the modern threat landscape. Ransomware attacks are not a matter of 'if', but 'when'. A well-architected backup and recovery strategy, incorporating modern principles like immutability and air-gapping, is the ultimate safety net. While the technical nuances can be complex, the cost of inaction – data loss, operational downtime, reputational damage, and potential fines – far outweighs the investment in robust data protection. Prioritize testing, understand your RPO/RTO, and foster collaboration between your IT and security teams. Your data's continuity depends on it.

Arsenal del Operador/Analista

  • Enterprise Backup Software: Veeam Backup & Replication, Commvault, Dell EMC Data Protection Suite.
  • Cloud Backup Solutions: Druva, AWS Backup, Azure Backup.
  • Immutable Storage Providers: Platforms offering WORM (Write Once, Read Many) capabilities.
  • Testing & Simulation Tools: Environments for testing restore procedures regularly.
  • Security Information and Event Management (SIEM): For monitoring backup logs and detecting suspicious activity.
  • Key Books: "The Practice of Cloud System Administration" (deals with related operational aspects), industry whitepapers on ransomware resilience.
  • Certifications: CompTIA Security+, Certified Data Privacy Solutions Engineer (CDPSE), vendor-specific backup certifications.

Preguntas Frecuentes

  • Q: Can cloud backups protect against ransomware?

    A: Yes, but with caveats. Cloud backups are effective if they are immutable, air-gapped, and isolated from your primary network. Standard cloud storage without these protections can still be compromised.

  • Q: How often should I test my backups?

    A: Ideally, you should test restores regularly – at least quarterly, if not monthly, for critical systems. Full DR tests should be conducted annually.

  • Q: What is an air gap in backup?

    A: An air gap is a security measure where a backup system is physically isolated from other networks, meaning there is no connection to the internet or the internal network. This makes it inaccessible to ransomware.

  • Q: Is tape backup still relevant?

    A: For long-term archival and offline, air-gapped storage, tape remains a cost-effective and reliable option. Its physical isolation is a significant defense against network-borne threats like ransomware.

El Contrato: Asegura Tu Resiliencia Digital

Your contract is sealed with the understanding that data is your most valuable asset. The challenge now is to apply this knowledge. Take one critical application or dataset within your organization. Map out its current backup strategy. Identify potential weaknesses against a sophisticated ransomware actor. Develop a remediation plan that incorporates at least one of the advanced strategies discussed: immutability, air-gapping, or dedicated SaaS protection. Document this plan. The true test of knowledge lies not in learning, but in implementing.

at No comments:
Labels: , , , , , , ,
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)